Skip to content
Felix
  • Topics
    • My List
    • Felix Guide
    • Asset Management
    • Coding and Data Analysis
      • Data Analysis and Visualization
      • Financial Data Tools
      • Python
      • SQL
    • Credit
      • Credit Analysis
      • Restructuring
    • Financial Literacy Essentials
      • Financial Data Tools
      • Financial Math
      • Foundations of Accounting
    • Industry Specific
      • Banks
      • Chemicals
      • Consumer
      • ESG
      • Insurance
      • Oil and Gas
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Project Finance
      • Real Estate
      • Renewable Energy
      • Technology
      • Telecoms
    • Introductory Courses
    • Investment Banking
      • Accounting
      • Financial Modeling
      • M&A and Divestitures
      • Private Debt
      • Private Equity
      • Valuation
      • Venture Capital
    • Markets
      • Economics
      • Equity Markets and Derivatives
      • Fixed Income and Derivatives
      • Introduction to Markets
      • Options and Structured Products
      • Other Capital Markets
      • Securities Services
    • Microsoft Office
      • Excel
      • PowerPoint
      • Word & Outlook
    • Professional Skills
      • Career Development
      • Expert Interviews
      • Interview Skills
    • Risk Management
    • Transaction Banking
    • Felix Live
  • Pathways
    • Investment Banking
    • Asset Management
    • Equity Research
    • Sales and Trading
    • Commercial Banking
    • Engineering
    • Operations
    • Private Equity
    • Credit Analysis
    • Restructuring
    • Venture Capital
    • CFA Institute
  • Certified Courses
  • Ask An Instructor
  • Support
  • Log in
  • Topics
    • My List
    • Felix Guide
    • Asset Management
    • Coding and Data Analysis
      • Data Analysis and Visualization
      • Financial Data Tools
      • Python
      • SQL
    • Credit
      • Credit Analysis
      • Restructuring
    • Financial Literacy Essentials
      • Financial Data Tools
      • Financial Math
      • Foundations of Accounting
    • Industry Specific
      • Banks
      • Chemicals
      • Consumer
      • ESG
      • Insurance
      • Oil and Gas
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Project Finance
      • Real Estate
      • Renewable Energy
      • Technology
      • Telecoms
    • Introductory Courses
    • Investment Banking
      • Accounting
      • Financial Modeling
      • M&A and Divestitures
      • Private Debt
      • Private Equity
      • Valuation
      • Venture Capital
    • Markets
      • Economics
      • Equity Markets and Derivatives
      • Fixed Income and Derivatives
      • Introduction to Markets
      • Options and Structured Products
      • Other Capital Markets
      • Securities Services
    • Microsoft Office
      • Excel
      • PowerPoint
      • Word & Outlook
    • Professional Skills
      • Career Development
      • Expert Interviews
      • Interview Skills
    • Risk Management
    • Transaction Banking
    • Felix Live
  • Pathways
    • Investment Banking
    • Asset Management
    • Equity Research
    • Sales and Trading
    • Commercial Banking
    • Engineering
    • Operations
    • Private Equity
    • Credit Analysis
    • Restructuring
    • Venture Capital
    • CFA Institute
  • Certified Courses
Felix
  • Data
    • Company Analytics
    • My Filing Annotations
    • Market & Industry Data
    • United States
    • Relative Valuation
    • Discount Rate
    • Building Forecasts
    • Capital Structure Analysis
    • Europe
    • Relative Valuation
    • Discount Rate
    • Building Forecasts
    • Capital Structure Analysis
  • Models
  • Account
    • Edit my profile
    • My List
    • Restart Homepage Tour
    • Restart Company Analytics Tour
    • Restart Filings Tour
  • Log in
  • Ask An Instructor
    • Email Our Experts
    • Felix User Guide
    • Contact Support

Active vs Passive Investing

Active vs Passive Management investigates the differences between active and passive investment management and analysis the arguments in favor of each investment approach, backed up by a number of different academic sources.

Unlock Your Certificate   
 
0% Complete

8 Lessons (24m)

Show lesson playlist
  • Description & Objectives

  • 1. Active vs. Passive Management

    03:51
  • 2. Arguments for Passive Investing

    04:59
  • 3. Identifying Closet Index Funds

    01:57
  • 4. Identifying Closet Index Funds Workout

    03:30
  • 5. Active Share

    03:53
  • 6. Active Share Workout

    01:42
  • 7. Arguments for Active Investing

    03:17
  • 8. Active vs Passive Investment Tryout


Prev: Modern Portfolio Theory Next: Index Investing

Arguments for Passive Investing

  • Notes
  • Questions
  • Transcript
  • 04:59

Investigation into the arguments in favor of passive portfolio management.

Downloads

No associated resources to download.

Glossary

active management Asset Management investment management passive management portfolio management
Back to top
Financial Edge Training

© Financial Edge Training 2025

Topics
Introduction to Finance Accounting Financial Modeling Valuation M&A and Divestitures Private Equity
Venture Capital Project Finance Credit Analysis Transaction Banking Restructuring Capital Markets
Asset Management Risk Management Economics Data Science and System
Request New Content
System Account User Guide Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Log in
Transcript

The first argument in favor of passive management is theoretical on a purely mathematical basis. The average performance of active funds should match the market return since active fund managers are participants in the market and abnormal returns within a portfolio should be a zero-sum gain across the whole Market since the fund manager that buys an outperforming stock must have bought it from someone who isn't experiencing that good performance since they don't own the stock anymore.

Another way of thinking about this as suggested in 1991 by William shop. After whom the sharp ratio is named is to say that if the market is made up of active and passive investors, then the passive investors will earn the return of the market since they are passively holding the stocks within the market and therefore the active managers must also on average and the return of the market since together active and passive investors. Make up the entire Market between them.

This implies that there is no point paying the higher fees for active management since on average active managers should generate the same return as passive managers. And the best that you can do is just to earn the return of the market as cheaply as possible through a passive fund.

In addition to the theory there have been an extensive number of academic studies carried out over a number of years to suggest that active managers on average do underperform their benchmarks after their fees are taken into account which backs up the theoretical point from before that. There's no point in paying the higher fees for active funds and a better alternative would be to invest in a passive fund.

This is however only looking at the average return of active managers and within this average there will be some portfolio managers who outperform the average and some who will underperform it. So if an investor picks a good fund manager, they would be able to beat the market that does then raise the question as to whether it is possible to identify a good portfolio manager in advance. This is easy to do at the end of a period but for an investor to earn that good performance, they would need to have invested in the fund at the beginning of a period it is possible to look back at past performance. But as all the financial adverts tell us past performance is no guarantee feature performance.

But is it an indicator at all? There is some evidence that the performance of good fund managers isn't sustained over time and that performance declines with time.

Originally from a paper by Mark Carhart in 1997, which found no Persistence of performance due to fund manager skill and more recently a study carried out by S&P Dow Jones indices found that only 36% of the top quartile Us by managers for the year ended June 2018 remained in the top quartile for each of the next two years and less than 2% of the top quartile Farm managers for the year ended June 2016 remained there for each of the next four subsequent years suggesting that top quartile fund managers in one period cannot consistently remain top quartile managers over time.

This would then indicate that using past performance as an indicator of identifying good for managers is not a reliable approach.

So if active managers are underperforming on average, why is this the case? Despite portfolio manager roles typically being held by those with substantial experience of making investment decisions one suggestion. Is that within Equity markets the distribution of stock performance around the market average is not symmetrical but rather positively skewed.

So that the best performing stocks perform a lot better than the average but there isn't the same corresponding effect for Worse performing stocks. This means that it is going to be harder for an active manager to identify the really high performing stocks and overweight them in their portfolio due to the relatively low number of these stocks a portfolio manager who has not overweighted these very good stocks in their portfolio will struggle to outperform The Benchmark the final argument against active funds and in the favor of passive funds is that there are a number of closet index funds. This means that although these funds describe themselves as active funds and charge management fees accordingly. They're Holdings closely match those of the index.

Such funds are highly unlikely to beat their Benchmark despite charging higher fees to their client.

These funds do Market themselves as active funds which raises challenges for investors to identify those funds that are closet index funds or which have Holdings very close to the benchmark.

Content Requests and Questions

You are trying to access premium learning content.

Discover our full catalogue and purchase a course Access all courses with our premium plans or log in to your account
Help

You need an account to contact support.

Create a free account or log in to an existing one

Sorry, you don't have access to that yet!

You are trying to access premium learning content.

Discover our full catalogue and purchase a course Access all courses with our premium plans or log in to your account

You have reached the limit of annotations (10) under our premium subscription. Upgrade to unlock unlimited annotations.

Find out more about our premium plan

You are trying to access content that requires a free account. Sign up or login in seconds!

Create a free account or log in to an existing one

You are trying to access content that requires a premium plan.

Find out more about our premium plan or log in to your account

Only US listed companies are available under our Free and Boost plans. Upgrade to Pro to access over 7,000 global companies across the US, UK, Canada, France, Italy, Germany, Hong Kong and more.

Find out more about our premium plan or log in to your account

A pro account is required for the Excel Add In

Find out more about our premium plan

Congratulations on completing

This field is hidden when viewing the form
Name(Required)
This field is hidden when viewing the form
Rate this course out of 5, where 5 is excellent and 1 is terrible.
Were the stated learning objectives met?(Required)
Were the stated prerequisite requirements appropriate and sufficient?(Required)
Were the program materials, including the qualified assessment, relevant and did they contribute to the achievement of the learning objectives?(Required)
Was the time allotted to the learning activity appropriate?(Required)
Are you happy for us to use your feedback and details in future marketing?(Required)

Thank you for already submitting feedback for this course.

CPE

What is CPE?

CPE stands for Continuing Professional Education, by completing learning activities you earn CPE credits to retain your professional credentials. CPE is required for Certified Public Accountants (CPAs). Financial Edge Training is registered with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) as a sponsor of continuing professional education on the National Registry of CPE Sponsors.

What are CPE credits?

For self study programs, 1 CPE credit is awarded for every 50 minutes of elearning content, this includes videos, workouts, tryouts, and exams.

CPE Exams

You must complete the CPE exam within 1 year of accessing a related playlist or course to earn CPE credits. To see how long you have left to complete a CPE exam, hover over the locked CPE credits button.

What if I'm not collecting CPE credits?

CPE exams do not count towards your FE certification. You do not need to complete the CPE exam if you are not collecting CPE credits, but you might find it useful for your own revision.


Further Help
  • Felix How to Guide walks you through the key functions and tools of the learning platform.
  • Playlists & Tryouts: Playlists are a collection of videos that teach you a specific skill and are tested with a tryout at the end. A tryout is a quiz that tests your knowledge and understanding of what you have just learned.
  • Exam: If you are collecting CPE points you must pass the relevant CPE exam within 1 year to receive credits.
  • Glossary: A glossary can be found below each video and provides definitions and explanations for terms and concepts. They are organized alphabetically to make it easy for you to find the term you need.
  • Search function: Use the Felix search function on the homepage to find content related to what you want to learn. Find related video content, lessons, and questions people have asked on the topic.
  • Closed Captions & Transcript: Closed captions and transcripts are available on videos. The video transcript can be found next to the closed captions in the video player. The transcript feature allows you to read the transcript of the video and search for key terms within the transcript.
  • Questions: If you have questions about the course content, you will find a section called Ask a Question underneath each video where you can submit questions to our expert instructor team.