Introduction to Interest Rate Swaps - Felix Live
- 59:32
A Felix Live webinar on Interest Rate Swaps.
Downloads
Glossary
Transcript
Good morning, good afternoon, good evening for some of you maybe, and with that, a very warm welcome to this Felix live session, Introduction to Interest Rate Swaps. My name is Thomas Kraus.
I am head of financial products here at Financial Edge, and I will, as a former swaps trader, guide you through the session here today. And of course, as always, let's start with a very quick look on the agenda. So what exactly are we going to talk about here? We're going to start with a quick overall introduction to swaps, then talk a little bit about the interest rate swap cash flow mechanics, and we're focusing on the fixed-to-floating interest rate swaps here.
We will then take an intuitive look at the interest rate risk that is embedded in those instruments.
We will have a look at the fundamentals of interest rate swap valuation, so the core principle behind that, and then we will finish this up with a look at some common application examples. Now let's get started with the content, and as I said, we're going to start with an overall introduction to swaps. And of course, this first sentence that you can see here on the slide is pretty much the standard definition of any financial swap, because it's actually really hard to come up with this one-size-fits-all definition of swaps because they are all so different.
If you think about CDS, for example, you think about FX swaps, cross currency swaps, interest rate swaps, equity swaps, they all sort of have common elements, but of course, the underlying mechanics are significantly different.
But one thing they all have in common, and that's then basically the classic definition of a financial swap, is that they are the agreement between the two counterparties here to exchange two series of cash flows. And that's quite different to, for example, a forward contract, where usually the agreement is to exchange either payment versus asset or just a net cash payment at one particular point in the future, and that means once the exchange has happened, the trade is finished. In case of a swap, we have usually regular points in time on which those cash flows or even assets are exchanged.
And in case of an interest rate swap, the simple kind of reason as to why these things are called interest rate swaps is that both cash flows that the counterparty is exchanging here are linked, or are basically determined by interest rates.
And of course, such an agreement to exchange two streams of payments based on interest rates only really makes sense if there's some sort of a difference between the interest rates that we're exchanging.
And that is then obviously where we start to realize that there are many potential type of interest rate swaps, because these interest rates that are exchanged can differ in many significantly different ways.
I would say, though, that the vast majority of interest rate swaps that you might come across in reality is falling into the first category here, and that's fixed for floating swaps.
More precisely, this is single currency fixed for floating swaps.
That means that the two counterparties here exchange a fixed interest rate that is basically set at trade inception or agreed upon at trade inception, versus a floating or variable interest rate that will then adjust or be adjusted automatically to the current level of interest rates in regular intervals. And that is then, as I said, that is in a single currency. In other words, we have a dollar interest rate paid fixed, a dollar interest rate, or variable dollar interest rate being received. As you can see here, there are certain naming conventions for the counterparties involved in such a transaction.
We talk about payers and receivers.
The one thing to remember here always is that payer and receiver is always, no exception there in case of fixed for floating swaps, basically determined by who does what on the fixed rate. So the payer is the party that pays the fixed rate, the receiver is the party that receives the fixed rate, and we can then obviously derive from there what happens on the floating side. So we're going to talk a lot more about those fixed to floating single currency swaps. As I said, that's pretty much the vast majority of the market, so we're going to look at this.
But we should also be aware that there are other types of interest rate swaps that maybe in terms of numbers of trade and notionally, et cetera, and liquidity even, are not quite as dominant, but they still exist, and they are still being used, so we should be basically familiar with those types. And the, I'd say, second most important category of interest rate swaps then are those basis swaps, which generally are categorized or are characterized by the fact that both cash flows that are, or streams of cash flows that are exchanged here over time are linked to a variable rate, i.e., no fixed payment. That means both parties are making payments that are not known entirely at the point in time where the swap is entered into.
And again, the same that I said earlier applies.
This exchange of two floating rates only really makes sense when we're exchanging floating rates that differ in one way or the other.
And that, again, can take many different forms.
And here are three that I too believe are worth knowing. There's more, but at least let's look at those because they seem to be the most Frequently traded ones. There's, for example, what I would call a reference rate basis swap, which means the difference between the two floating rates or the different floating legs that is exchanged is that we're using different reference rates in the same currency with the same tenor. So basically an overnight rate, for example, in dollars, but not the exact same fixing here.
But you would see, for example, swaps where we exchange SOFR, which is the secured overnight financing rate, versus EFFR, which is the effective federal funds rate.
Both overnight rates, but because the way these numbers are determined is slightly different, there's a small spread between those, and we can obviously enter into swaps where we're paying SOFR, receiving EFFR, vice versa.
That might be usually done for sort of mismatches on the hedging side of things.
Then we have the tenor basis swap. That is something that you do not necessarily find in every currency anymore since the LIBOR transition has gone through.
But we still have currencies where there's meaningful activity in IBOR contracts. And so in euros, for example, we still have three months and six months Euribor, and a tenor basis swap would be, as an example, a swap where we're using the same currency, also the same kind of reference rate, i.e.
Euribor in both cases, but we're exchanging Euribors with different tenors.
So for example, a three-months Euribor is what I pay, and a six-months Euribor is what I receive. Again, that's very often used to address some sort of basis risk that has built up in a swap portfolio, but there might even be other reasons to trade such a thing. And then the third example that I wanted to basically talk to you about here is a cross-currency basis swap.
And here the main difference is obviously that we have two reference rates that we're exchanging here, and both are in different currencies.
So this could be, for example, where I pay US dollar based SOFR into the swap and I receive the euro ESTR, which stands for European short-term rate.
Both overnight rates, but this time in different currencies.
And that is then when you think about, for example, cross-currency swap contracts, usually one of the instruments that is involved in those structures. Okay. So these are then, as I said, quite a few different types and obviously we can vary given the fact that these are OTC instruments.
But let's stick to what is the vast majority and accounts for really a large percentage of interest rate swap trading on a daily basis, and those are those single currency fixed for floating swaps.
Now, starting point to realize is those contracts are still traded over the counter, right? Yes.
A lot of changes happened, central clearing mandates. We had obviously also the push to get those instruments traded on exchange-like, or more exchange-like way. So a lot of these standard swaps nowadays are traded through swap execution facilities or similarly named electronic trading platforms. But still, they are OTC contracts, which means we can tailor them as a liquidity absorber, as a liquidity user here to meet our specific requests. And that in turn means that before the price can be agreed, we need to sort of know a couple of really important items here because they are pricing relevant, right? So for example, what would I like to know? And I'm not going through this by the order of importance, just to let you know which things are of course relevant. First, you would typically start maybe with the tenor, i.e. for how long do I want this interest rate to be exchanged, right? Or this contract to last where exchanging fixed versus floating for two years, for five, 10, 30, 50.
And that of course is immediately, I hope, intuitive simply because we all know there's a term structure of interest rates, i.e.
different interest rates, at least in some market circumstances apply to, or in most market circumstances I should say, apply to different times to maturity and sometimes these differences can be quite significant, and therefore the starting point would probably be the maturity. Then of course you would think about the notional, i.e. the size of the trade, right? Simply because these two numbers together, the notional and the tenor, will probably give you the majority of what you need to know in order to determine the underlying interest rate risk if you think about DV01 or anything like that.
And that will sort of help you to make a judgment call as the liquidity provider here, what risk am I exposing my portfolio to and how quickly will I be able to maybe pass that risk on into the market using different types of hedges, et cetera. And that's obviously very important information. Now, a reminder here, the notional on an interest rate swap, on a single currency interest rate swap we should say, is not going to be exchanged.
That's pointless because that would mean I give you 100 million, you give me 100 million. We might as well not do this.
So what is then the real role of the notional? As I said, it's determining the interest rate risk, and the reason as to why the notional is important for determining the interest rate risk is it's a calculation basis for all interest rate payments that we're going to exchange in the future, right? In an interest rate swap, we're exchanging interest rates. And those are usually expressed in percentage.
And to turn a percentage number into an actual amount of money, we need a notional amount to base these percentage calculations on.
And that is then the purpose of the notional.
We also need to discuss the reference rate.
In other words, what really is the rate we're referring to when it comes to determining the variable payments of the floating leg. Right? In many currencies, there might just be one, but in others, we have two or even more than that.
And sometimes they all have similar characteristics, sometimes they could be very different. And so it's important to agree on what exactly the reference rate is before we even start thinking about pricing.
So typical things to determine here or to decide in between is are we using an overnight rate like SOFR, like EFFR, SONIA, ESTA, TONA, SARON, et cetera, or are we using IBOR rates, the interbank offered rates that have been obviously dominating the interest rate swap business for many decades, but since the LIBOR transition has been completed, obviously have lost ground quite significantly. But as I mentioned before, there are currencies like yours, for example, where we still see a reasonable amount of swaps business linked to those rates. Once we have determined the reference rate, very often, usually I'd say, we also have determined the reset frequency. Because typically in a normal plain vanilla swap instrument, reference rate, tenor, and reset frequency are the same. Right? Meaning if I have a six months EURIBOR as the reference rate in a euro swap, or I have SOFR, which is an overnight rate on a USD OIS. So that means that the reset frequency in our IBOR example would typically be semi-annually.
In other words, we have a six months underlying reference rate.
That means twice a year we're going to reset the floating rate. In case of SOFR, which is an overnight rate, we have a daily reset of the interest rate. Right? Because SOFR ever only applies for a day, or well, that's not quite true because obviously the SOFR for today to Monday will apply for the next three days.
But generally speaking, during the week, it's a daily reset, or let's say business daily reset, then we're on the safe side. Okay.
And then we also have to discuss the payment frequency.
Again, in the classic swap market where we had our IBOR-linked products, the payment frequency usually is aligned to the tenor of the reference rate and to the reset frequency. Meaning if we have semi-annual reset, we also would have typically semi-annual payment.
And while we have stuck to the convention that the tenor of the reference rate is usually identical to the reset frequency in OIS, we are now seeing a difference between OIS and the IBOR-linked products simply because usually we do not exchange the floating rate on a daily basis on OIS. Right? Well, an OIS, as we'll determine on the next slide, are those swaps where the underlying floating rate is an overnight rate like SOFR, et cetera.
And the simple reason for this is it's just really inefficient to exchange daily payments, right? So imagine you're swapping $50 million fixed versus float, and then we have now a fixing rate of 3.8 or whatever, and then 3.8% on 50 million for one out of 360 days. That's a reasonably small amount of money to send around. And therefore, instead of having daily payments, what we usually do here, and again, it's an OTC contract, you can obviously agree on different things, but very often we have now an annual payment on the OIS leg. And that creates some complexity that we're going to talk about a little later.
And then we have pretty much most of the information, and obviously we need to know who the counterparty is to kind of think about potential counterparty exposures, et cetera.
But generally speaking, we then have a lot of information that we need to actually come up with a price. And the price in case of an interest rate swap or the quote we're giving is always going to be the fixed rate in this particular case.
So we're going to quote, let's say 3.5 to 3.52. And that means if a client is willing to pay us a fixed rate, we would ask them to pay 3.52% to us, and if they want to receive, we're going to pay them 3.5, the usual bid offer spread and its interpretation as we are used to from pretty much any other product. And that is then obviously the fixed rate that needs to be paid to receive the floating stream of cash flows. Now, the reset frequency on the fixed leg obviously is not relevant simply because, as we said, we determine the fixed rate at inception, and then it doesn't change over the life of the swap.
The payment frequency, however, is something we can decide upon. This could be, again, quarterly, semi-annually, annually as for any other instrument.
And one point just to mention here, it is entirely possible and very often happened in reality that we have different payment frequencies on the fixed and on the floating leg. Like for example, you see here at the example at the bottom of the screen, this was a five-year fixed versus floating.
Floating was semi-annually and annual payments on the Fixed rate, and that meant that every 12 months there was a fixed payment, and every six months, there would've been a floating payment, which was, as I said, absolutely non-spectacular.
This is a pretty common way of swap cash flows to look like. Okay, so you heard me throwing around terms like OIS, and this is then one of the things where I would say it's always good to really not rely on the assumption here that everybody understands the same when you hear three-letter acronyms.
Because when you are talking about interest rate swaps, frequently people use IRS, people use OIS.
And while I believe OIS is a relatively clear terminology, IRS is a little bit less clear what exactly we mean. Because in essence, IRS stands for interest rate swap, and that, in my mind, could mean a whole lot of different things.
The overnight index swap is known as a specific type of interest rate swap, and that's the one where the floating reference is an overnight rate, i.e. a rate that applies from one day to the next business day, like the SOFR, SONIAS, et cetera, of this world. So whenever you have a swap where the underlying is a standard SOFR, a standard SONIA, or anything equivalent, then it's safe to call this an overnight index swap, i.e. an OIS.
Interest rate swap, I have heard in most cases being used for the classic type of interest rate swap. In other words, how swaps used to work for decades, as mentioned earlier. We have IBOR as the reference rate. So if you're, technically speaking, trading a five-year swap in euros annual fixed versus semi-annual floating, and the reference rate is six months EURIBOR, technically speaking, that is probably okay to call an IRS, and OIS would be five years versus ESTO.
That is the most common understanding, I believe.
But as I said, never really rely on the fact that everybody sees it this way. So always just check in case there is any doubt what exactly your counterparty of the conversation is talking about.
Okay, that's just as a side note. Now let's have a look at the actual cash flow mechanics.
How do these contracts actually differ? And we have, as I said, now this scenario where in some currencies you have two significantly different cash flow mechanics depending on what the underlying reference rate is.
And we're starting with the old way, and that's, as I said, something we can still see in euros. So for example, we have here a two-year payer interest rate swap with annual fixed payments and six months EURIBOR, and it doesn't say it explicitly, so I added here semi-annually paid. And so what that means is, as we've discussed before, we have every six months a payment on the floating leg, and every 12 months, we have a payment on the fixed leg. And now whenever there's a date on which both the fixed and the floating payment is made, we don't exchange both amounts, but we just calculate the net amount and only that is exchanged. That's what we call cash flow netting, and that is, of course, for reasons of efficiency, but also for risk reduction.
So tends to be a very easy to agree upon thing. Okay, so that's the general idea.
But now let's just take a quick look at how exactly and when exactly are those cash flows determined.
As I said, and we're just kind of using some example here.
So let's just nice round numbers. Let's say a 4% rate for two years, and then six months EURIBOR is the reference rate.
So when we enter into the trade, i.e.
at the transaction date, which is today, let's say, so 6th of November. Apologies, I'm using the European way of writing down the date.
So 6th of November, we're trading today, and that's when we set the 4% here on the fixed.
So that's determining these two payments.
This doesn't change over the life of the swap.
And we have also agreed that the floating rate payments are linked to six months EURIBOR, which is fixed in Frankfurt on a business daily basis, and I think it's published at around 11:00 Frankfurt time. So we have entered into the swap today.
The question is, when does it start? And which EURIBOR fixing is the one that we have to use? Well, swaps start usually with a T+2 settlement convention. That means we're trading today, but the actual start date for a swap is two business days later, i.e. next Tuesday, which brings us, I believe, to the 10th of November 2026. That's a spot date. Now, what happens there? What's the relevance? That is the date on which interest rate on both legs starts to accrue.
So basically, although we have agreed to enter into an interest rate swap, before the start of Tuesday, the clock hasn't started ticking. We have agreed on the interest rate on the fixed leg, but interest rates are not accruing yet simply because the swap officially hasn't started.
So that means interest starts to accrue Tuesday next week.
And we know that the reference rate is six months EURIBOR.
Now, the question is, which six months EURIBOR are we using? Are we using the six months EURIBOR that will be fixed next Tuesday, question mark? And the answer is no, because EURIBOR is fixed also with a T plus two settlement convention, meaning today's six months EURIBOR, i.e. the six months EURIBOR fixing from the 6th of November 2026, is applying or applicable for a six-month period that starts two business days from now, which means from the 10th of November 2026 to the 10th of May 2026, assuming that's a good business day.
2027, sorry. So basically, what that means is, because it's now after 11:00 Frankfurt time, we know the first six months rate already. That means we know the floating payment, or we can calculate the floating payment that will have to be made at this point in time. What we do not know yet, though, is this, this, and this payment. So these are the three unknowns for this particular interest rate swap.
This rate here will be known six months from now, this rate here 12 months from now, and this one here 18 months from now. Okay, so that's the classic mechanic we have in in arrears fixing, so the reference rate is determined before the period has even started, and then there's an in arrears payment.
In other words, at the end of the whole interest rate period, the interest payment is made. And that is, as I said, the classic way and has worked like this in pretty much any currency for many, many years. But then we had the LIBOR scandal, we had the LIBOR transition, we had the introduction of these new risk-free rates that are now being used as presented in many currencies. And now in many currencies, we are exclusively trading OIS. In euros, we do both, but let's stick with the currency here just for consistency, and we're now switching from IRS to OIS. So we're now looking at a two-year payer OIS where we're having annual fixed and also annual floating payments. But as we know, ESTA is an overnight rate and therefore is reset daily.
A lot of things are exactly the same as before. What means we're trading these swaps with a T plus two a day count.
So we're trading today, 6th of November, and that means we're accruing interest from the 10th of November 2026.
We have annual payments. In this case, we have annual payments on both fixed and floating leg, which means every payment in the future will happen on a netted basis because they always fall on the same business day, so we just have two payments in the future. Both will be netted, so relatively simple cash flow structure.
The question, however, is which ESTA are we going to use for the first interest rate fixing, and on which day will it be available? Now, of course, we have learned that the swap starts to accrue interest on Tuesday 10th of November.
So what we really are going to use to determine the interest for that period is the ESTA that applies from the period on the 10th to the 11th of November. And that's basically the reference rate we're going to use.
And now the question is, when will this be known? Okay.
So generally speaking, the way this works is that those overnight rates are transaction-based rates, meaning we observe for, not we, but the calculation agent, which usually is a central bank in this particular country, is observing those daily money market transactions.
They get reported the notional amounts that have been exchanged and the interest rate that has been agreed.
So real underlying overnight cash transactions, and then they calculate some sort of volume-weighted average out of this. Okay. And then that is obviously something that requires to include all transactions that happened on a day, and that means we can only ever really calculate those reference rates or start thinking about the fixing calculation once the market has basically closed.
In other words, there's no transaction that might come afterwards.
And that means all the data is only available at the end of a business day, and because these numbers are relatively important because we have a whole lot of derivatives or cash flows linked to those numbers, we want to make sure that these numbers are accurate. And it's also a huge number of transactions that need to be considered.
So typically, those numbers are then, those weighted averages are calculated overnight and then released to the public next business day, meaning we take for the first day the ESTA that applies from the 10th of November to the 11th of November, which will be known usually in the early hours of morning of the 11th of November.
There was a question here around is a payment based on the daily rates, or does the rate lock in for the entire period for an OIS? The classic OIS is using daily rates.
So you will only use this first ESTA fixing for the first day, and then on the 12th of November, to stick with our example, you would take the then new fixed ESTA, and that applies To the period from the 11th to the 12th, and so you will continue doing that. There is an exception to that, and those are what we call term SOFR-linked swaps. There's a term SOFR fixing that the CME, for example, publishes on a daily basis.
And so that is then basically a six-month rate based on SOFR.
So in a way, then, that works very similar to the classic IBOR swap, that there is an advance fixing and an arrears payment.
The thing to be aware of, though, is that the usage of those swaps is, as by regulation, severely limited.
These can only really be used if their purpose is the hedge of a lending instrument that has basically the same interest rate basis, i.e., is linked to term SOFR. So that's not really how the standard swap market works. That's just an exception for some non-financial end users that has been granted. But the typical OIS operates that every day we are resetting the OI, or the overnight rate, and that also means that we need to think about what then determines, actually, the whole floating payment that is supposed to happen 12 months from now. Right? And we're now coming to the complexity that I mentioned. Because you can say, well, okay, so all that happens here really is that I should have paid interest, if we're starting on the 10th of November, then I should have made my first interest rate payment on the floating leg on the 11th. Right? So overnight rates apply overnight from 10th to 11th. I should have paid that interest amount on the 11th. Now, we have agreed on the swap that we're not going to exchange interest rate on a floating leg on a daily basis, because that would mean transferring 50 quid around the world every day. Right? And that's massively inefficient.
So instead, we have agreed that the floating payment for the entire year is made at the end of the 12 months period.
That, however, if we don't make any adjustment, would leave the receiver of the floating leg with a financial disadvantage. Right? Because they should have received their first payment after day one, and now they receive even the payment for day one 364 days later.
And as we know from time value of money, usually it's better to get money earlier than later, because then you can reinvest it, interest on interest, and so on and so forth. So it cannot really be that we're just memorizing the interest amount and then pay it all in one go at the end of a 12 months period, because the counterparty receiving this payment will be losing out on interest on interest. And that's then basically the complexity.
So how can we get around this? Well, basically, we're not using just a simple average of overnight rate fixings there over the 12 months period to calculate the floating payment. We're using something that's called a compounded average. And here, the official formula that I believe you find in an ISDA master agreement on how these things are calculated is on the bottom left here of the slide.
The table shows you the intuition or the basic approach of how this formula, or what's the thought process behind the formula. So we're looking at a seven-day example here, just to keep things relatively straight. A swap that started on a Monday and then obviously finishes on the Monday, the week after.
And what we're seeing here is the different fixings that apply for an overnight period starting from that day. Okay? So basically, from Monday to Tuesday, the SOFR fixing that was then available on Tuesday morning, i.e., backward-looking, was 525, which means for the first day, from Monday to Tuesday, the floating rate payer should have paid 525 adjusted by day count convention down to one day. Right? And if we're assuming here, and that's maybe a little bit unrealistic, but it is how it is, that the swap notional was $1, then we can just basically say, okay, what should have been paid on Tuesday, right? So the payment on Tuesday should have been the notional amount of the swap times the interest rate of 5.25, times one day, divided by 360, because as you know, or might know, SOFR is a U.S. money market product, and U.S.
money market day count convention is actual 360.
And if you do the math, then you get this 0.000145833.
So that is the payment that we should have made to our counterparty on that Tuesday.
And there you see why it's pointless to transfer these amounts of money, because that technically wouldn't even work.
But generally, obviously, this would normally be 100 million or something, and then the amount can be transferred. But that aside, it would still be very small amounts, very inefficient.
So instead, what we're now doing is the next overnight rate, the one that now applies from Tuesday to Wednesday, which was then 526, is not applied just on the initial notional of one, but on the notional of one, plus the interest that we should have paid the day before, but we didn't.
Right? So this and add these two together and then apply the SOFR of 526, again, for a day over 360, and that then gives us the next interest rate payment that we should have made on Wednesday.
Again, we don't do this, so we just rinse and repeat.
So basically, instead of paying immediately, we're just adding the instrument or the interest that we already owe to our counterparty into the calculation process.
So the interest that we should have paid on Monday will cause interest on interest from our perspective that we need to pay on Tuesday and vice versa, and then we can continue this.
And the only real sort of meaningful difference here over the next couple of days is Friday.
And there we have to use a factor of three, and the simple reason is when you lend money on Friday, even if it's overnight, it basically is for three days because on weekends, no payment systems operate or classic payment systems operate. So that would be a three-day waiting.
And then you get to the actual amount of money that or to the actual interest amount of money that we need to pay.
So here that would be the amount. And of course, it's relatively straightforward to calculate an interest rate out of that because we know the present value was one, the future value is 1.001022328, and now it's a seven-day period we can just easily rearrange to solve for the interest rate, and that would've been 5.25769. And then obviously, that would be the compounded average floating rate for this specific OIS. So yes, we delay payments, but there is through that formula here an automatic compensation for whoever receives the floating payments for getting paid later. So that's how the market has solved that problem, or challenge, let's say, because it's certainly not a problem.
Okay. With that, let's move away from the cash flow mechanics and just have a quick look at interest rate risk in swaps, and I think that is wonderfully intuitive. We're looking at this through an example. So now we're actually moving to dollars, and we're assuming we have entered a two-year dollar OIS, and we were receiving a fixed rate of 3.75 versus SOFR, both legs paid annually. And we did that this morning.
And let's just assume that this was just a purely speculative trade. So we took a directional view on interest rates. No hedge or anything like that.
We just took a punt here on the direction of interest rates.
And then the question is: In which direction would we, being in the swap that we have just outlined, prefer SOFR to move in the future? So we're receiving a fixed rate.
That doesn't change over the next two years.
What we pay is adjusted on a daily basis.
And of course, it then makes sense to say, well, we would clearly prefer SOFR going down over time, simply because that means what we get remains unchanged.
What we pay gets smaller and smaller and smaller, and that would be certainly P&L positive. That leads us to the answer here then.
Intuitively, the receiver in an IRS, my fixed rate receiver, would prefer to see the floating rate to decrease in the future. Receivables constant, payables decline. We talked about that. And then, of course, the pay on the other side, the fixed rate payer would prefer to see an increase in the floating rate. And that kind of leads us to the conclusion and intuitively, purely intuitively, fixed rate receivers benefit from a decline in rates, fixed rate payers benefit from a rise in interest rates.
That is hopefully really easy to digest and in line with what you expected to hear anyway.
The interesting thing about that approach, though, as intuitive as it is, it will technically speaking only really allow us to calculate the financial success that a certain instrument had at the end of the instrument's life.
So technically speaking, we would need to know all floating rate fixings, i.e. what effectively we paid on floating or received on floating so that we can determine what was the actual financial success of this instrument.
But that is, of course, not enough in the professional finance space where we need to be able to assign a mark-to-market value to any instrument that we have in our portfolios at pretty much any point during the day.
Certainly when they are liquid and easy, relatively easy to value instruments like interest rate swaps.
So the question then is: How can we value an interest rate swap before its maturity date when we do not know all the floating fixings that are required for this calculation that I've just suggested? And so we're looking at this in a slightly idealized way, because we are in our example here assuming the same swap that we looked at just a minute ago.
Where we say, okay, we have a two-year dollar OIS, 375 is the fixed rate.
OIS is paid annually. SOFR, that is the reference rate. And we did this this morning.
Now we're staying on the same day.
So still we are at the trade date, and now we're assuming that in the afternoon Two-year dollar OIS rates have declined by two basis points, i.e. we're now talking 3.73%.
So then the question is, how can we calculate the mark-to-market value of our position? And because we make this assumption that we're still at the trading day, that's really easy, right? And reality, of course, is a little bit more complex, but still the general foundational concept remains more or less unchanged. So basically what we can simply do here is to assume, okay, we entered a certain swap position in the morning receiving a fixed rate, meaning now we're long rates, i.e., we benefit when interest rates are going down, and we would obviously lose if interest rates are going up.
And if I wanted to neutralize that market risk, then what I would have to do, or one thing I could do to achieve that, would be to enter into an offsetting swap. In other words, do the exact opposite of what I've done this morning. So here's us. Let's visualize this.
And from the swap this morning, we're receiving 375 and we're paying SOFR that's paid annually.
If we wanted to close that risk, we could go into the market and trade out of this swap, and we'll basically do the opposite swap at 3.73. That's now what we have to pay to either the same counterpart or another counterpart, and in exchange, we're going to get SOFR also paid annually. And because we're doing this on the same day that we entered the transaction in the morning, we can safely assume that those two cash flows will cancel each other out perfectly. Right? Because we're going to use the exact same SOFR fixings at the same point in time. That's the perfect world, hence, it won't be that easy all the time. But in this example, it is. And so what's then left really is the two fixed cash flows, and that is, we have 3.75% coming in every year, and we have 3.73% going out.
If we have traded this on the same notional amount, which of course we should have done, then basically what that means is we have two basis points net left at the end of year one and at the end of year two because that is leaving us with positive two basis points.
And this, of course, is now something we need to multiply with the notional, and then we need to multiply that with the day count fraction, so how many days over a basis. And because this is a future payment, we now have to multiply that with a one-year discount factor because this payment is one year in the future, and we always like to look at things from a PV perspective, i.e., we have to discount it by a year.
And the exact same thing just using discount factor of two years now would be done and we have now the present value of these two basis points in a year's time and in two years' time. We now sum up the PVs.
And basically, the sum of the net present value of all the swap's cash flows, that is the mark-to-market value of an interest rate swap. And so the interesting thing to take away here is that on the previous slide we said intuitively when we enter into a receiver swap, what we really want to see is SOFR to go down.
Now we're looking at this slide and SOFR hasn't moved at all simply be-- it's the same day. SOFR hasn't even been fixed once for this swap. But yet we have already made two basis points PV back to today in profits. And now the question is, of course, where does this profit come from? Well, it comes from a decline in the swap rate.
Right? So we ended at 375 the morning, and now it's 373.
Now, the question then is, why has the swap rate declined? And of course, the only right answer to this is that obviously there was a lot of receiving interest in the market, so supply and demand.
But of course, conceptually what could have led to this receiving interest. And that's basically in, obviously sometimes it's just flow driven by hedging or anything else, but whenever you do see bigger moves in the macro rate space, that's often a sort of change in positioning, often driven by a change in market view. Right? So if you were now to think that interest rates, swap rates or bond yields or whatever were to go down dramatically over the next couple of weeks because of a change in the macroeconomic landscape, then one way to position yourself would always obviously be to buy government bonds, right? And then if you're right and the yield decline, the price of the government bond goes up.
Another way to position yourself for this would be to receive fixed on an interest rate swap, and then if rates start to fall and more people receive on the swap side, then swap rates will go down and you will have that mechanism that we've just explained that flushes positive P&L into your portfolios.
Even though SOFR itself might not have really moved because the Fed hasn't cut rates or anything like that, right? So that's I think then obviously for us to think about in another session when we're thinking about obviously yield curves and expectations and forward rates and all that kind of jazz.
But generally speaking, hopefully you get a bit of a sense of that these contracts can indeed be valued relatively comfortably at any point in time. So we do not have to wait until we know the last cash flow, the floating leg. Okay. With that, let's move into the application just to wrap this up.
I believe I said at least at the beginning that this is an instrument that is Obviously being used in enormous num-- or well, not enormous, but in quite large numbers. So lots of daily transactions, lots of notional that's been traded.
And then, of course, the question is why is it so popular? And of course, the answer to that is it is so flexible, it allows us to do so many things. And a lot of people have interest rate risk, and want to change that or manage that one way or the other. And so a lot of interest rate swaps are entered into for hedging purposes or just to change the interest rate characteristics of either a financing instrument or an investment instrument.
So here, a classic example, we have a corporate borrower. They went to their corporate bank, have taken out a loan that is on a floating basis. So they are paying EURIBOR plus 1.5% here over, let's say, the five-year term.
And they are looking for a way to turn this floating rate funding into fixed rate financing simply because they don't want to have uncertainty.
So what they do currently, they pay floating on the loan. And so what they would now do on the swap is they would pay fixed into the swap to receive floating.
And that floating rate would then be passed on to the loan. So of course, what we should do here on the swap, we should make sure that the fixing date of the EURIBOR on the swap and the fixing date of the EURIBOR on the loan are not too far apart, ideally the same day. And that's possible because swaps are OTC instruments.
And then if we manage to do that, then those two should always cancel each other out. And then basically from a borrower's point of view, they pay 3.7 into the swap, and they have to pay 1.5% into the loan. And that leaves us with a net payment of 5.2%. And on the right here, you see a couple of EURIBOR scenarios. Just as a reminder that, yes, the net payment is 5.2 in all cases. But of course, what happens here on the loan is still we have to pay EURIBOR plus one and a half as the borrower.
So that means if EURIBOR goes to 7%, then on the loan we have to pay 8.5%. That doesn't change.
But we then get a relative significant net payment from the swap, because what the swap is going to look like here is we pay 3.7 into the swap and we receive 7% out. And those 7% are now covering our 7% EURIBOR on the loan, basically again, back to 5.2%. So that is here one way to turn a floating rate loan synthetically into a fixed rate loan.
And we can do it the other way around as well.
So we have here now a bond issuer that has issued a fixed coupon bond and sold that paper at par, and the coupon was 4.5%. So basically nice clean yield to maturity of 4.5% being paid as a coupon 100% to the bond investors on, let's say, a semi-annual basis or whatever. It doesn't really matter for our example here.
And now the issuer is looking to swap that into floating, maybe because they believe interest rates are about to go down or something. So they are paying fixed on the bond, so now they want to receive fixed on a swap.
So they call a market maker for a five-year swap, and they get the two quotes here, 4.04 to 4.06. And then, of course, usual way to interpret bid offer, the liquidity taker here, the market taker is paying the bid offer spread. So if we have a borrower here that is looking to receive and the quote is 4.04 to 4.06, then they will receive 4.04%. Let's ignore this 4.5 for a moment.
We'll come back to that in a minute.
And then we'll pay SOFR flat into the swap on a floating leg. And then because the coupon is 4.5% and they receive 4.04%, one could argue that the financing cost is 4.04%, what they pay into the swap, and then the 0.46% that they need to sort of pay on top to get the 4.04 to the 4.5 that they pay. So the net cost is 4.5%. So basically, this here is then requiring us to pay SOFR. So what we could say is SOFR plus 46 basis points is the net funding cost for this corporate here or for the bond issuer.
And I think that would be sufficient.
Sometimes you might say, well, the borrower might actually prefer to have the exact same cash flow that they need to pay to bond holders coming out of the swap. So there might be the desire from the borrower to not receive 4.04, but to receive 4.5. Now, of course, that's then an off-market swap because the market price for five-year swaps at that point was a lot lower. It was 4.04 to 4.06. Right? If now the borrower would ask for a 4.5% rate, what that means is the market maker would pay 46 basis points over or above the current market price.
And that, of course, will not be done for free.
But what would happen because both legs here are paid on an annual basis and perfect alignment here.
The market maker would, of course, be happy to add 0.46% every year to this leg.
If in exchange, the client would then add those same 46 basis points on the floating leg.
And then basically we have created an off-market swap where instead of the 404, we're now paying the 4.5% to the borrower, and in return, the borrower pays us SOFR plus 46 basis points. Same result as above, maybe a little bit more elegant.
I would not have necessarily preference, but that, I guess depends on who you're talking to here. So that would be the second application. And then both are hedging transactions.
So let's have a look at the trading application.
One of the things we have already talked about when we're thinking about the risk and the valuation part, we can take directional views with interest rate swaps.
If I believe interest rates are about to go up, I pay the fixed rate.
If I believe interest rates are about to go down, then I receive the fixed rate.
And then obviously from taking pure directional risk, we can also move to taking curve risks. So we can, for example, trade a steepening or flattening that we expect to happen.
So the steepening trade here would be that we would expect, for example the curve, for example, between the ten- and two-year or two- and ten-year point to steepen, meaning ten-year rates going up relatively to two-year rates. And to position myself for that, I would pay fixed on the ten-year point of the curve.
I would receive fixed at the two-year point of the curve.
And similar to bond world, because of the different tenor here, the interest rate risk for the same amount of notional would be quite significantly different.
So we would have to adjust the notionals here to be overall duration neutral or DV01 neutral, because when you take a curve view, you do not necessarily want exposure to a parallel move up or down.
You just want to be exposed to a steepening, in this case, of the curve, i.e. you would pay fixed on the ten-year point and receive fixed at the two-year point for a much larger notional to just adjust the difference in duration.
And if you were expecting the curve to flatten, then obviously you would just do the complete opposite. And then one step up is if you don't really have a pure view on the steepening, but you think that a curve is becoming more concave or less concave, then you could enter into a butterfly transaction.
So here the example is that we expect the, let's say it's a two fives, tens, then the five-year point to go up relatively to the two- and ten-year points, and then we would pay fixed on the five-year point, and we would receive fixed at two and ten.
And there's several ways in thinking about weighting.
One very common one is the 50/50. So you would just basically take, let's say, plus 25K DV01 here on the five-year point, and then you would enter into 12.5K and 12.5K each at the two- and ten-year point. So basically, to offset your DV01 at the five-year point, you take 50% on the two and 50% on the ten-year point. And then again, you do not have exposure against a parallel shift, at least not initially.
Convexity, of course, is something to consider later on.
But for the first couple of basis points of PNL in case of a perfect parallel shift will in fact be zero. But obviously if five years were going up relatively to a ten, then this trade would pay off.
If the opposite happens, you would have negative PNL impacts.
And if you were expecting the curve to become less concave, you would again just do the opposite.
And with that, ladies and gentlemen, I have reached the point.
I've basically covered everything I wanted to do.
So thank you very much for your participation here today.
Thanks for the questions, and have a great rest of your Friday and obviously a great weekend.
Okay. Take care of yourselves and hopefully, I will have you on board in one of our future sessions soon.
Remember the feedback form and put in which topics you would like to see covered.
And of course, also any potential follow-up questions you have.
Hear from you and, well, hope to see you soon. Bye.